柏拉图的《理想国》研究

【英语】 柏拉图的《理想国》研究 2007-11-07

无下载权限

teiler

知名会员
管理成员
592911944487372275.jpg
一条新条目已被添加到资源中心

条目内容介绍:
书名: Plato's Republic: A Study
作者: Stanley Rosen (Author)
出版社: Yale University Press (November 11, 2005)
语言: English
ISBN-10: 0300109628
ISBN-13: 978-0300109627

Book Description
In this book a distinguished philosopher offers a comprehensive interpretation of Plato’s most controversial dialogue. Treating the Republic as a unity and focusing on the dramatic form as the presentation of the argument, Stanley Rosen challenges earlier analyses of the Republic (including the ironic reading of Leo Strauss and his disciples) and argues that the key to understanding the dialogue is to grasp the author’s intention in composing it, in particular whether Plato believed that the city constructed in the Republic is possible and desirable.

Rosen demonstrates that the fundamental principles underlying the just city are theoretically attractive but that the attempt to enact them in practice leads to conceptual incoherence and political disaster. The Republic, says Rosen, is a vivid illustration of the irreconcilability of philosophy and political practice.

Review
"Highly persuasive as a refutation of the Straussians as well as of those who wish to accuse Plato of totalitarianism on one hand or philosophical incompetence on the other. Plato scholars of every stripe will be forced to respond to this book’s main claims." -- Jacob Howland, University of Tulsa

"The most comprehensive and detailed commentary on and interpretation of Plato’s Republic in English. Stanley Rosen is one of the most original interpreters of Plato alive." -- Drew A. Hyland, Trinity College, Hartford, Connecticut

"A smart and insightful commentary. The book is a welcome addition to the corpus of Plato scholarship. . . .Highly recommended" -- Choice

About the Author
Stanley Rosen is Borden Parker Bowne Professor of Philosophy and University Professor at Boston University. His previous books include The Elusiveness of the Ordinary and Hermeneutics as Politics, both published by Yale University Press.

下载链接:
要查看条目、给条目评分或添加评论, 请访问【英】柏拉图的《理想国》研究
您添加的评论将在下面的帖子中显示。
 

anderers

初级会员
回复: 【英】柏拉图的《理想国》研究

这本书在北大借阅率很高,借了几次都没借到。
Rosen这本书酝酿了有20多年吧,只见到陆陆续续的一些文章。整部书的疏解还得好好看看。
 

wojiuzheyicila

普通会员
回复: 【英】柏拉图的《理想国》研究

呵呵,竟然有此好书,坛主功德无量啊。施特劳斯学派对柏拉图以及古典哲学/文学的解读和注疏自成一派,按照这条思路做学问的在中国也渐成显学。坛主真是有心人,再次致谢。
 

barth

普通会员
我对此条目的意见和评分...

评论:

本书是斯坦利·罗森的代表作之一。罗森是施特劳斯的弟子,与allan bloom各执东西学派的牛耳。喜欢。
罗森的书中译本有《启蒙的面具》《诗与哲学之争》:)

要查看条目、给条目评分或添加评论, 请访问【英】柏拉图的《理想国》研究
您添加的评论将在下面的帖子中显示。
 

frankb

新会员
回复: 【英】柏拉图的《理想国》研究

我觉得楼主说得不错,古代的民主和现代的民主是不同的,古代没有现在意义上的那种
个体的自由和尊重,那个时候的民主还是一种比较朴素的氏族民主,个体虽然可以表达
意愿,但个体并不作为一个最高的实体得到尊重,那个时候宗教和国家的地位高于个人,
个人往往束缚于宗教和国家。现代意义的个人主义,应该自斯多葛以及基督教思想之后影响而产生的,不过那个时候,虽然尊重个体,但并不把享受,生存权当做最终目的,只有等近代霍布斯之后,把生存当做一个基本的起点建筑社会哲学时,现代意义上的个体主义才得以产生。
苏格拉底的死,我认为表达了哲学和政治之间的紧张这个论断是对的。
 

aidolphin

普通会员
回复: 【英】柏拉图的《理想国》研究

Rosen离施派其实挺远的。但几乎可以说,他是施派诸多传人中古典学最出色的一个。
 

njuzmwu

普通会员
回复: 【英】柏拉图的《理想国》研究

A·E·泰勒的柏拉图研究和施特劳斯等人的研究有截然的不同。可以说,施氏倾注太多个人的感情色彩在古典学的研究之中,他某种程度上是在以古典学隐喻现实的政治。
 
顶部